Alleged accomplice in Portage murder case to face jurors Tuesday

Timothy Sandifer IV
Timothy Sandifer IV

VALPARAISO — The man accused of pulling the trigger during an April shooting death in Portage will not see jurors until early next year, but the trial for his co-defendant is scheduled to begin Tuesday, officials said.

Jury selection is to begin that morning for Timothy Sandifer IV, 20, of Gary, who is accused of helping to murder Darion Anderson, 20, of Hammond, on April 29 at a home in Portage, officials say.

He is charged with counts of aiding in a murder in perpetration of a robbery and aiding in an attempted robbery, records show.

Police say Sandifer is responsible for bringing the gunman to the scene. That alleged gunman is Montrell McLaurin Jr., 20, of Gary, who is charged with murder, murder in the perpetration of a robbery and robbery with firearm enhancements for each count, records show.

An uncooperative witness forced a delay in McLaurin's case and the unusual move of releasing him without bond.

Porter County Deputy Prosecutor Mary Ryan has said the delay until Jan. 6 was necessary because the out-of-state witness in question, who is needed to refute claims of self defense by the McLaurin, has repeatedly dodged interviews and a hearing with her office.

Ryan said it is anticipated that the witness in question would testify he spent April 29 with Anderson and others, and Sandifer showed up to the Portage home with a 9mm gun. Anderson also reportedly had a gun.

When the group decided to buy marijuana, Sandifer contacted his "weed guy," identified as McLaurin, according to Ryan.

McLaurin came into the house armed with a Micro Draco, which is described as an AK-style pistol that is reportedly popular among criminals and gangs. He was reportedly joined by another armed male.

"The witness would testify that it was weird that Sandifer brought the 'weed guy' and the other male into the home for a marijuana sale instead of the transaction occurring outside," according to Ryan.

The witness says he believed McLaurin was trying to separate Anderson from his friends and then watched as McLaurin pointed his gun at Anderson and said, "Hey don't move. Give me that gun," according to the motion for the delay.

When Anderson turned to grab his gun, McLaurin pulled the trigger on the Micro Draco, the witness reported. Anderson reportedly never had a chance to grab his gun.

While McLaurin is now claiming self defense in the shooting, that would be refuted by the testimony of the witness in question, Ryan said. Prosecutors say the motive of the shooting was robbery.

Gallery: Recent arrests booked into the Porter County Jail

Matthew Matlock
Arrest date: Oct. 31, 2024 Age: 48 Residence: Valparaiso, IN Booking Number: 2404712 Charges: Criminal recklessness, felony
Kelly Davis
Arrest date: Oct. 31, 2024 Age: 55 Residence: Valparaiso, IN Booking Number: 2404717 Charges: OWI, misdemeanor
Timothy Tucker
Arrest date: Oct. 30, 2024 Age: 27 Residence: Valparaiso, IN Booking Number: 2404709 Charges: Intimidation, felony
James Wyatt
Arrest date: Oct. 30, 2024 Age: 52 Residence: Valparaiso, IN Booking Number: 2404705 Charges: Sex offender/failing to register, felony
David Starha
Arrest date: Oct. 30, 2024 Age: 58 Residence: Sawyer, MI Booking Number: 2404711 Charges: OWI, misdemeanor
Kyle Patterson
Arrest date: Oct. 30, 2024 Age: 27 Residence: Porter, IN Booking Number: 2404700 Charges: Possession of methamphetamine, felony
Stacy Johnston
Arrest date: Oct. 29, 2024 Age: 39 Residence: Portage, IN Booking Number: 2404697 Charges: Possession of methamphetamine, felony
Ryan Little Jr.
Arrest date: Oct. 29, 2024 Age: 21 Residence: Portage, IN Booking Number: 2404690 Charges: Neglect of a dependant, felony
Ryan Little Sr.
Arrest date: Oct. 29, 2024 Age: 43 Residence: Portage, IN Booking Number: 2404691 Charges: Neglect of a dependant, felony
Taylor Casbon
Arrest date: Oct. 29, 2024 Age: 27 Residence: Valparaiso, IN Booking Number: 2404693 Charges: Drugs/dealing, felony
Katherine Hunt
Arrest date: Oct. 29, 2024 Age: 35 Residence: South Bend, IN Booking Number: 2404699 Charges: Theft, felony
Jessica Smith
Arrest date: Oct. 28, 2024 Age: 44 Residence: Valparaiso, IN Booking Number: 2404682 Charges: Drug offense, felony
Christopher Grant II
Arrest date: Oct. 28, 2024 Age: 21 Residence: Portage, IN Booking Number: 2404684 Charges: Resisting law enforcement, felony
Shannon Chavez
Arrest date: Oct. 28, 2024 Age: 38 Residence: Portage, IN Booking Number: 2404677 Charges: Dealing in methamphetamine, felony
Brian Gauch
Arrest date: Oct. 28, 2024 Age: 37 Residence: St. Charles, IL Booking Number: 2404685 Charges: Identity deception, felony
Alyssa Perzo
Arrest date: Oct. 27, 2024 Age: 31 Residence: Portage, IN Booking Number: 2404663 Charges: Battery, misdemeanor
Tiffany Williams
Arrest date: Oct. 27, 2024 Age: 35 Residence: Gary, IN Booking Number: 2404660 Charges: OWI, felony
Joel Marasco
Arrest date: Oct. 27, 2024 Age: 40 Residence: Lake Station, IN Booking Number: 2404661 Charges: OWI, misdemeanor
April Chamblis
Arrest date: Oct. 27, 2024 Age: 18 Residence: Portage, IN Booking Number: 2404666 Charges: Domestic battery, felony
Alejandro Fuentes
Arrest date: Oct. 27, 2024 Age: 19 Residence: Fort Wayne, IN Booking Number: 2404667 Charges: Obstruction of justice, felony
Kristina Bell
Arrest date: Oct. 27, 2024 Age: 29 Residence: LaPorte, IN Booking Number: 2404662 Charges: OWI, misdemeanor
Tyler Bohacik
Arrest date: Oct. 27, 2024 Age: 28 Residence: Valparaiso, IN Booking Number: 2404658 Charges: OWI, misdemeanor
Starr Barber
Arrest date: Oct. 27, 2024 Age: 43 Residence: Portage, IN Booking Number: 2404671 Charges: Possession hypodermic syringe or needle, felony

all articles